2012-10-08

Christ’s Ventriloquists

by Neil Godfrey

Many of us may be interested in David Hamilton’s recent post of a list of “lessons learned” from his reading of Eric Zuesse’s Christ’s Ventriloquists: The Event that Created Christianity.

This work argues Paul’s letter to Galatians effectively marks the birth of Christianity. [Eric Zuesse has since commented that I am flat wrong here -- see his comment below. 12:00 pm]

I had a different perspective on the book that I may discuss some time here, but till then have a look and a think about David’s views.

One note from David:

I found Eric’s methodology to be interesting, but not quite convincing. He is onto one thing though: even scholars who claim to not be captured by confessional interests still do not question all of their assumptions, such as the assumption that Paul was (or was not) honest.

Another work by Seuss

  • 2012-10-08 09:55:26 UTC - 09:55 | Permalink

    Neil, you misrepresent my Christ’s Ventriloquists, when you say “This work argues Paul’s letter to Galatians effectively marks the birth of Christianity.” It does not argue that; it contradicts that and is inconsistent with that.

    • 2012-10-08 11:59:16 UTC - 11:59 | Permalink

      Sorry Eric. My memory obviously failed me. You are welcome to post a correction to explain what it does argue and how it is inconsistent with that.

      • 2012-10-08 14:25:49 UTC - 14:25 | Permalink

        Till or unless Eric responds, I have had another look at Eric’s manuscript and am reminded that he argues that Paul used the letter to Galatians to describe the event that effectively started Christianity — Galatians 2:11-21, Paul’s conflict with the James party at Antioch.

        • reyjacobs
          2012-10-10 23:31:48 UTC - 23:31 | Permalink

          Which amounts to the same since the event being narrated is pure fiction.

  • David Hillman
    2012-10-09 04:16:26 UTC - 04:16 | Permalink

    I think Eric does say that the letter does describe how Pauline and later Christianity started, but that it did not start Christianity as such as he choses to call the pre-Pauline movement which he thinks Jesus started Christianity also.

    • 2012-10-09 20:43:07 UTC - 20:43 | Permalink

      From my reading, I would say that Galatians was not the start of Christianity, but it describes the events from 2-3 years prior that did amount to the creation of Christianity. Galatians supplies the justification and the best evidence.

  • Leave a Reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

    You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

    Powered by sweet Captcha