The "Nugget" Theory

[S]ound historical method must lead a scholar to distrust any source much of which can be shown to be false — unless truly reliable material exists outside that source as a check.

Sometimes, however, we find that a scholar writes history

on the principle that a historian can safely mine “nuggets” out of otherwise worthless ore.

Both quotations are from Chester G. Starr in “The Credibility of Early Spartan History”, (Historia: Zeitschrift fur Alte Geschichte Bd. 14, H. 3 (Jul., 1965), pp. 257-272) …. http://www.jstor.org/stable/4434883

Chester G. Starr

2 Comments

Pingback: Vridar » Saul’s Folly: The King Can’t Be a Jack of All Trades

Pingback: Vridar » The evidence of ancient historians

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Anony on Which “Bone” Was Eve Made From?: “I’m amazed that educated people think that because Adam’s “rib” was removed that men would have one less rib!…” Apr 22, 21:55

Giuseppe on Gnostic Interpretation of Exodus and Beginnings of the Joshua/Jesus Cult: “I am building on Detering's case here with an original interpretation (I think).” Apr 22, 17:51

Giuseppe on Gnostic Interpretation of Exodus and Beginnings of the Joshua/Jesus Cult: “Detering’s text appears to speak of another Nag Hammadi text that I am unable to decipher.…” Apr 22, 17:48

Blood on Gnostic Interpretation of Exodus and Beginnings of the Joshua/Jesus Cult: “All this is reminiscent of C.W. Leadbeater in "The Christian Creed" (1898) where he proposed that "Pontius Pilate" was merely…” Apr 22, 15:32

MrHorse on Reconstructing Papias and a new look at the Synoptic Problem: “Apparent Jason Beduhn thinks the so-called Marcionite Gospel may actually be pre-Marcionite, and postulates Luke as a Marcionite-neutral redaction of…” Apr 22, 04:24

MrHorse on Reconstructing Papias and a new look at the Synoptic Problem: “It would pay to look at different ways recent authors have looked at (or are looking at) The Synoptic Problem.…” Apr 22, 04:02

JaredMithrandir on Reconstructing Papias and a new look at the Synoptic Problem: “My view is that "Q" is Hebrew Matthew, which may have been just a collection of speeches from how some…” Apr 22, 03:19

Tige Gibson on Expulsion of the Palestinians, Part 11: “Especially in those days, God and religion provide the moral justification for the out-group hatred, not the other way around.…” Apr 21, 18:12

Klaus Schilling on Reconstructing Papias and a new look at the Synoptic Problem: “OK, the link was necessary to show the large difference to Doherty. Instead of a division inro rural Jewish vs.…” Apr 21, 12:52

Vridar

2017-11-22