The “Nugget” Theory |

[S]ound historical method must lead a scholar to distrust any source much of which can be shown to be false — unless truly reliable material exists outside that source as a check.

Sometimes, however, we find that a scholar writes history

on the principle that a historian can safely mine “nuggets” out of otherwise worthless ore.

Both quotations are from Chester G. Starr in “The Credibility of Early Spartan History”, (Historia: Zeitschrift fur Alte Geschichte Bd. 14, H. 3 (Jul., 1965), pp. 257-272) …. http://www.jstor.org/stable/4434883

2 Comments

Pingback: Vridar » Saul’s Folly: The King Can’t Be a Jack of All Trades

Pingback: Vridar » The evidence of ancient historians

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Lowen Gartner on Rank-Raglan hero types and Gullotta’s criticism of Carrier’s use of them: “"I am the one they will, in turn, misrepresent and attack" -- I wish you would be shown to…” Aug 21, 03:52

Neil Godfrey on Rank-Raglan hero types and Gullotta’s criticism of Carrier’s use of them: “On this blog we have shown how seriously "they" misrepresented Earl Doherty's arguments; we have seen how seriously "they" misrepresent…” Aug 21, 03:17

Neil Godfrey on Rank-Raglan hero types and Gullotta’s criticism of Carrier’s use of them: “Past experience has taught me that the group will circle the wagons to protect one of their own. The wagons…” Aug 21, 02:58

A Buddhist on Rank-Raglan hero types and Gullotta’s criticism of Carrier’s use of them: “Neil Godfrey: I seriously think that you should submit this series of blog posts to some more academic source –…” Aug 20, 23:18

Neil Godfrey on Hermann Detering and Robert M. Price: “It went into spam. Not sure why. Possibly the length of it triggered a spam meter. Check out our comments…” Aug 20, 22:45

John MacDonald on Hermann Detering and Robert M. Price: “I posted a comment but it disappeared?” Aug 20, 20:42

John MacDonald on John the Baptist foreshadowed in Homer’s Odyssey?: “The death of John the Baptist seems to serve a neat literary role in Mark. While John the Baptist's "quick"…” Aug 20, 20:29

db on Further Daniel Gullotta Disrepresentation of Carrier’s On the Historicity of Jesus: “Per the podcast above: [23:20] Gullotta >>> In my studies of mythicism — I am actually not that interested…” Aug 20, 18:05

db on Scholarly Snobbery and Wikipedia (again): “Sparkes, A. W. (1988). "Idiots, Ancient and Modern". Politics. 23 (1): 101–102. doi:10.1080/00323268808402051. Schlier (1966:215–217) gives an…” Aug 19, 23:21

Vridar

2017-11-22