The “Nugget” Theory

by Neil Godfrey

[S]ound historical method must lead a scholar to distrust any source much of which can be shown to be false — unless truly reliable material exists outside that source as a check.

Sometimes, however, we find that a scholar writes history

on the principle that a historian can safely mine “nuggets” out of otherwise worthless ore.

Both quotations are from Chester G. Starr in “The Credibility of Early Spartan History”, (Historia: Zeitschrift fur Alte Geschichte Bd. 14, H. 3 (Jul., 1965), pp. 257-272) …. http://www.jstor.org/stable/4434883

2 Comments

Pingback: Vridar » Saul’s Folly: The King Can’t Be a Jack of All Trades

Pingback: Vridar » The evidence of ancient historians

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

A Buddhist on How Long Does Collective Memory Last?: “What one chooses to read can certainly guide what one thinks as normal. So maybe you should try actively looking…” Jan 22, 23:24

r.g.price on How Long Does Collective Memory Last?: “Whatever the case, its irrelevant because there is significant evidence that the Gospels aren't based on oral tradition anyway.…” Jan 22, 20:33

Aaron on Ancient History, a “Funny Kind of History”: “But the Emperor's new clothes are so extravagant” Jan 22, 19:22

Aaron on Bob Price — Did you really read Marx?: “I'm a big fan of his Bible Geek podcast but he used to occasionally drop in some political commentary (he…” Jan 22, 18:25

Martin Lewadny on Comments: “Thanks everyone for getting more specific about the Willi Braun material I referred to. Some good stuff there!…” Jan 22, 18:15

A Buddhist on Scholarship and “Mythicism”: When the Guilty Verdict is more important than the Evidence or Argument: “Roger Pearse: If I were to offer you a copy of JNGNM, would you accept it and read it?…” Jan 22, 17:34

r.g.price on Bob Price — Did you really read Marx?: “Yeah, my website started primarily with articles on economics, and politics, of which my views are certainly to the left.…” Jan 22, 16:57

john dauria on Bob Price — Did you really read Marx?: “I bet the good Robert is not so keen now on the Trump admin since it withdrew funding for a…” Jan 22, 16:45

Leigh Sutherland on Bob Price — Did you really read Marx?: “I think there is a lot of confusion out there that those of us who believe in a Market based…” Jan 22, 15:34

Vridar

2017-11-22