[Update 20 Nov 2016: The full text of Couchoud’s Creation of Christ is now available online.]
.
Here is a complete list of posts in this series listed in the order in which they appear in Couchoud’s book.
Volume I
Part 1 THE APOCALYPSES (168 B.C. to A.D. 40)
1. Pre-Christian Foundations of Christianity
I had earlier posted these without the same sorts of commentary as Earl Doherty’s forerunner? Paul-Louis Couchoud and the birth of Christ
These posts contained PDF files of:
The Foreword
Chapter one: Preliminary
Chapter two: The Profaned Temple (concerning the time of Antiochus Epiphanes)
Chapter three: The Dream of Daniel (the first appearance of the Divine Man/Son of Man as an entirely metaphoric figure)
Chapter four: The Revelations of Enoch (traces the evolution of this Daniel figure)
Chapter five: The Revelations of Moses (continuing the evolution of this figure into a real heavenly person)
2. John the Baptist and the foundations of Christianity
Chapter six of part 1, titled “The Prophet John the Baptist”
3. The first signs of Christianity
This looks at the earliest appearances of uniquely Christian terms for the Christ figure, Christian practices such as baptism and visionary experiences, and the break from John the Baptist. Chapter seven of part 1, titled “Elements of Christianity”.
Part 2 THE PROPHETS (A.D. 40 to A. D. 130)
4. The swarming of the prophets
Introduction to who was spreading the Christian movement and how. Chapter one of Part 2.
5. Earliest divisions in the Christian movement
Chapter two of Part 2. Titled “Divisions”
First half of chapter three of Part 2, titled “Struggles and Sufferings of St. Paul”
Second half of chapter three of Part 2. Couchoud argues that the Crucified Christ concept was largely the result of Paul projecting his own sufferings into a saving divinity.
8. The Crucified God: origin and original meaning of the concept
Chapter four of Part 2. This explains the mystical nature of the original concept of a crucified deity. Couchoud’s title, “The Crucified God”.
9. War of the heavenly Christs: John’s sacrificed Lamb versus Paul’s crucified God
First half of chapter five of Part 2. Titled “The Sacrificed Lamb”.
10. The Christ of John’s Revelation: nemesis of Paul’s crucified Christ
Second half of chapter five, Part 2.
Part 3 THE GOSPELS (A.D. 130 to A.D 150)
11. Christianity in the gap years, 70 CE to 120 CE
Chapter one of Part 3. This chapter looks at Christianity in the various Roman provinces. Couchoud’s title, “The Christian Provinces”.
12. Why early churches chose a book over living prophets
Chapter two of Part 3. Couchoud’s title for this chapter is “Conflicts”.
13. How Christ became flesh: the role of the celestial high priest
Chapter three of Part 3. Discusses the place of the Book of Hebrews. Title “The Celestial High Priest”.
14. Christ descends to earth: Marcion’s contribution to Christianity
Chapter four of Part 3. A related post is Marcion’s authorship of his Gospel: an overlooked question, that links to Professor Markus Vinzent’s blog where a contemporary scholar is re-opening this question. Title, “Marcion”.
15. Another explanation of Gospel origins from a Christ myth perspective
A section of the same chapter above. I doubled up here. Woops.
16. The earliest gospels 1 – Marcion’s gospel
Chapter five of Part 3. The Gospel of Marcion. Couchoud’s title, “The Good God on Earth (The Gospel of Marcion)”.
17. The earliest gospels 2 – the gospel of Basilides
First few pages of chapter six, Part 3. Title in Couchoud’s volume: “The Son and Heir of God (The Gospel according to St. Mark)”.
18. The earliest gospels 3 – the gospel of Mark
The remainder of chapter six, Part 3.
19. The earliest gospels 4 – Matthew
Chapter seven, Part 3. Title: “The Messiah of Israel (The Gospel according to St. Matthew)”.
Volume II
20. The earliest gospels 5 – gospel of John
Chapter eight, Part 3. Title: “God Incarnate (The Gospel according to St. John)”
21. The earliest gospels 6(a) – on the cusp of Luke
First part of chapter nine, Part 3. This brings us to Rome’s perspective and the beginnings of efforts to “catholicize” or bring some order to the chaotic scene of Christianity.
22. The earliest gospels 6(b) – Luke
Part of chapter nine, Part 3. Introduces the key role of Clement in the production of the gospel of Luke and much of the New Testament corpus. Couchoud’s title: “Jesus of Nazareth (The Gospel according to Saint Luke)”.
22. The earliest gospels 6(c) – Luke’s gospel
Continuing chapter nine, Part 3.
23. Couchoud on Acts of the Apostles
Continuing chapter nine, Part 3. Focus on the role of Clement and the function of the Acts as a catholicizing tract. Marcion is identified as Simon Magus.
24. Paul’s letter to the Romans and the formation of the canonical edition
Continuing chapter nine, Part 3. Further discussion of Clement’s editorial hand.
Continuing chapter nine, Part 3.
26. The Pastorals, a remedy for a grave defect in Paul’s epistles
Continuing chapter nine, Part 3.
27. 2 Peters, 1 Jude and 2 Revelations: the first New Testament
Concluding chapter nine, Part 3, and the likely role of Clement.
28. Jesus formed
Chapter ten, Part 3. Title, “Jesus Formed”.
Appendix I
The Gospel According to Marcion
Appendix II
The Historicity of Jesus
I missed Appendix II in the series of posts. I will add one to cover this when I get the opportunity.
Neil Godfrey
Latest posts by Neil Godfrey (see all)
- Is Everything a Question of Probability? - 2024-12-15 03:04:03 GMT+0000
- The Folly of Bayesian Probability in “Doing History” - 2024-12-13 05:51:46 GMT+0000
- Jesus Mythicism and Historical Knowledge, Part 4: Did Jesus Exist? - 2024-11-27 08:20:47 GMT+0000
If you enjoyed this post, please consider donating to Vridar. Thanks!
Yes, I do suggest that it would be a plus if the PDF files of the initial chapters could be brought in kilter with the rest of the book. This concerns the texts listed in 1. Pre-Christian Foundations of Christianity as follows:
Foreword (approx 2.2 MB pdf)
Apocalypses (168 b.c. – a.d. 40)
I. Preliminary (approx 1.8 MB pdf)
II. Profaned Temple (approx 2.2 MB pdf)
III. The Dream of Daniel (approx 3.3 MB pdf)
IV. Revelations of Enoch (approx 6.7 MB pdf)
V. Revelations of Moses (approx 2.8 MB pdf)
Converting those PDFs into regular postings would give us the convenience of reading “Couchoud Uninterrupted” all in the same smooth and flowing presentation style. This would require copying the relevant 29 pages into regular postings and injecting the same kind of formatting as in the rest of the set.
As it is undeniable that this spacious formatting, including the eminently readable Verdana font, the comfortable line spacing, and the judicious use of colors, makes reading this text — which might otherwise appear rather dense and rebarbative to many in the original edition — such a pleasant exercise.
One day. Will do. I need a bit of a break from it at the moment.
Hi Neil,
into the book that I’m reading in this days, Marcion and the Dating of Synoptic Gospels, Peeters 2014, by Markus Vinzent, I find a positive note about you:
Most recently Couchoud has been re-discovered by Neil Godfrey, a hobby New Testament scholar who runs the Vridar blog (vridar.wordpress.com) and who has a reliable summary of Couchoud’s work with a series of interesting commentaries on it.
(p. 143, n. 541)
The context is words of positive review about Couchoud:
… And although scholars may rightly reject most of the wild speculations of Couchoud, a critical reading of him is extremely rewarding. The poet knew his sources and he was prepared to unearth and make fresh and unorthodox connections which even today can inspire serious scholarship.
(p. 143)
Is there a way to get the pdf or epub of entire Creation of Christ of Couchoud? The idea of a Christ-myth storicized later by Marcion in a Gospel the first time seems very plausible to my eyes . . .
Happy New Year!
Giuseppe