2007-04-01

Existential Jesus — another review

Creative Commons License

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.

by Neil Godfrey

youngalexander has alerted me/the iidb list to a new review of John Carroll’s book.

It’s in The Age, a review by another sociology professor, Gary Bouma. Promising an extract next week.

I like many of the insights Carroll offers into the Gospel of Mark, and make heavy use of his footnotes. But I find JC’s (ie. John Carroll’s) sense of “spirituality”, however well integrated in his existentialist philosophy, just too much to handle. Carroll is using the text to express and explore his existentialism. I find it of interest that the gospel of Mark can lend itself to that. But he must read his understanding of “being” into the text. Unlike Carroll, I don’t know what Mark was thinking were the inner thoughts and feelings of any of the characters, and suspect he never for a moment thought his strictly literary and theological creations would have had any apart from what he gave them on the page. My interest is in understanding the text historically and to that end I crave any study that casts new light on the nature of the text. Carroll gives many tidbits of insights in that area, and that is where my interest ends.

Related Posts on Vridar

“When Jesus went out with a loud voice”... I earlier blogged about the "last shout" of Jesus before he left this world (When Jesus went out with a loud voice . . .) and one reader responded by ...
An experiment comparing gnostic and orthodox myths This post is a follow up from Jesus’ Baptism in the Context of the Myth of Water, Flight and Wilderness. I may come to see this attempt to compare the...
Jesus’ Baptism in the Context of the Myth of... An important consequence follows. If a myth is made up of all its variants, structural analysis should take all of them into account. -- Claude Lévi-S...
Why and when “Mark” wrote the first go... We have another argument (I don't mean evidence-free speculation) for when and why somebody sat down and wrote the first gospel, the one we know as th...
The following two tabs change content below.

Neil Godfrey

Neil is the author of this post. To read more about Neil, see our About page.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.