2007-03-10

First-thoughts on Review of “Existential Jesus”

Creative Commons License

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.

by Neil Godfrey

Disappointed in the Australian review of Carroll’s Existential Jesus. Have tried to track down a little on the reviewer, Andrew Rutherford, and closest I can find is that he’s “a Melbourne based reviewer”. His review does not demonstrate deep awareness of the issues involved. He says, for example, that Crossan has “shown” how a Galilean peasant like Jesus might become the focus of a religion. Well, Crossan has certainly attempted to show as much (that his Jesus is a fellow Irish freedom-advocate), but only from the basis of so many questionable assumptions and being content to leave so many inevitable questions unaddressed — check out Doherty’s review for starters. Rutherford’s review seems to be saying little more than Carroll is up the creek because he does not conform to respectable scholarly questions and established scholarly conclusions.

I have still to read the book, but pending its arrival I have to confess to some parting of ways at John Carroll’s own commentary. It goes further than the impressions I was left with over his Religion Report interview. I can handle Mark as an historical and literary document, but I feel less comfortable with seekers of “truths” behind human existence. I find nothing fearful at all, and everything richly meaningful, in base biological and physical explanations for everything. That, to me, is the only foundation of human cooperation that I can see holding when all else has failed, as fearful dreaming and searching for other “Truths Out There” always will.

Related Posts on Vridar

John Carroll on the Existential Jesus (live this t... Mark's Greek according to John Carroll (The Existential Jesus): (pics nicked from here. Two faces or one vase?) This is how Mark's Greek works -...
Link to Alison Cotes’ review of “The E... Have fixed the link to Alison Cote's review of "The Existential Jesus". Depending on your browser settings you may need to enlarge the image to read i...
Alison Cotes’ review of Existential Jesus (J... This review that was published in the Brisbane Anglican newspaper, in John Carroll's words, "quite brilliantly catches the flavour of what I have atte...
Existential Jesus is what the title says Picked up John Carroll's "The Existential Jesus" today. It is written more for those with a philosophical or religious mind. This book is John Carroll...
The following two tabs change content below.

Neil Godfrey

Neil is the author of this post. To read more about Neil, see our About page.

Latest posts by Neil Godfrey (see all)

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.