2015-06-09

Hidden Meanings and Memories

Creative Commons License

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.

by Neil Godfrey

It’s not always a happy experience to get to know too much about some of our favourite talents. Forgive my latecomer status to this little bit of knowledge — but I have just learned that Alice in Wonderland contains a number of scenes that were inspired by the author’s disdain for Darwin’s theory of evolution. Charles Dodgson (alias Lewis Carroll) was as reactionary as one could get in Victorian times. Thanks to Rachel Kohn’s Radio National program, The Spirit of Things, for alerting me to the “low down” on this work and its author: Decoding Alice in Wonderland. That led to David Day’s article, “Oxford in Wonderland.” Queen’s Quarterly 117.3 (2010): 403+

Alice_par_John_Tenniel_21One of the historic turning points in human intellectual history in this new era took place a few hundred yards from Lewis Carroll’s residence. This was the famous 1860 Oxford Darwinian Debate in which the bombastic anti-Evolutionist Wilberforce was verbally eviscerated by the rational pro-Evolutionary Thomas Henry Huxley. Known as “Darwin’s Bulldog,” Huxley’s victory became emblematic of the triumph of progressive rational science.

In Wonderland, Carroll’s satire of the Darwin debate takes place in the strange smoke-filled Kitchen of the Ugly Duchess. The Oxford counterpart of the Duchess’ Kitchen is one of the grand sites of the university: Cardinal Wolsey’s Great Kitchen. Built during the reign of Henry VIII, Oxford’s Great Kitchen has a massive hearth for roasting entire pigs and, like the Duchess’ Kitchen, was frequently filled with smoke.

The Great Kitchen was also the one part of the university that was directly under the authority of the Bishop of Oxford. Samuel Wilberforce, the son of the anti-slavery movement’s “Great Emancipator” William Wilberforce, was known to parliamentarians and political pundits as “Soapy Sam” because of his brash and illogical debating style. He was the perfect model for the logic-chopping, moralizing, and argumentative Ugly Duchess.

In this fantastic “Kitchen of Creation,” one can imagine these insane cooks mixing up a mad biological soup. Evolution is gone berserk. Uniformed fish and frog footmen seem to have just stepped out of the primordial ooze. A constantly shape-shifting baby appears to demonstrate “survival of the fittest” by preferring beatings to affection. Strangest of all, Alice’s attempt to nurse this child results in a strange backward form of evolution: from a boy into a pig.

Well, I always hated that ugly duchess and baby scene anyway!

Speaking of parallels there was an interesting article a while back on Εις Δοξαν looking at the eleventh labour of Heracles in which he was ordered to recover some golden apples: 

[The apples] were a gift from Gaia to Zeus and Hera at their wedding. These apples were the source of immortality for the gods and, interestingly, were guarded by a dragon, itself the offspring of Typhon and Echidna.

So, a tree of apples (fruit) that gave immortality which was guarded by a serpent–where have I read of such things before? Yes, this is obviously quite different from the Genesis account, but it is quite interesting that these elements–fruit, unnaturally long life, and a serpent–are all together in the same story.

I once used to sit mystified by such teasingly unrelated yet common elements appearing in both Greek and Biblical myths. But then Claude Lévi-Strauss rode into my bookshelf and opened up the possibility, even likelihood, of an anthropological link. Wajdenbaum has published along these lines and I hope to make time to try to see if the different structures of these common elements can be explained in ways  not unlike Lévi-Strauss’s social-anthropological explanations of the various mutations of South American myths.

I used a few hours on a plane the other day to catch up on what Tom Harpur’s mythicist argument is all about. His book, The Pagan Christ, is too much a recap of what Massey and Kuhn have interpreted to be the meanings of Egyptian texts and symbols and is very light on presentation of the direct evidence itself to enable readers to understand how these interpretations are justified. I don’t deny a link between Egyptian religious ideas and Christianity but Harpur does not establish a definite link or explain adequately anything more than a handful of isolated tropes.

Again on “spot the meaningful parallel” yesterday I took a photo of monks in Bangkok and after looking at it again was struck with how it reminded me of the Beatles’ crossing Abbey Road. Another instance I could have used to make my point in When is a parallel a “real parallel”.

Just as I concluded a series of posts addressing Moses and the Exodus and its relationship to Akhenaten’s revolution I see Bible History Daily has picked up the theme and renewed the momentum with an article Akhenaten and Moses.

 

The following two tabs change content below.

Neil Godfrey

Neil is the author of this post. To read more about Neil, see our About page.

If you enjoyed this post, please consider donating to Vridar. Thanks!

13 Comments

  • Greg Pandatshang
    2015-06-09 03:54:25 GMT+0000 - 03:54 | Permalink

    OT:

    Neil,

    Since yesterday or the day before, I’ve been getting spam popups every time I come Vridar. None on any other sites. fyi

    • Tariq
      2015-06-09 04:27:55 GMT+0000 - 04:27 | Permalink

      Neil,

      Me too…

    • Tim Widowfield
      2015-06-09 04:47:38 GMT+0000 - 04:47 | Permalink

      Can you take a screenshot? This should not be happening.

  • 2015-06-09 20:24:41 GMT+0000 - 20:24 | Permalink

    Alice in Wonderland a coded tale against evolution? Curioser and curioser.

  • Bee
    2015-06-10 05:57:48 GMT+0000 - 05:57 | Permalink

    By the way? As I recall, in Japanese, the symbol for man, or man walking, is a wide-stepping, two-legged stick figure. I’ve seen a Japanese news photo of a PM, capturing that long step. Apparently deliberately invoking the somewhat pictographic symbol.

    In the study of Art, we note such parallels all the time. Do not know if John knew Yoko at the time.

    Evolutionists need not feel discriminated against by the way; Carroll parodied dozens of academic theories at Oxford. As his odd “wonderland.”

    • Neil Godfrey
      2015-06-10 06:36:54 GMT+0000 - 06:36 | Permalink

      In the study of Art, we note such parallels all the time.

      Indeed. Also in literature. But when it comes to the Gospels then the learned enclave seems to cry Foul.

  • Reader
    2015-06-22 16:33:49 GMT+0000 - 16:33 | Permalink

    Just came across this on the BBC:

  • Reader
    2015-06-22 16:35:46 GMT+0000 - 16:35 | Permalink
    • Neil Godfrey
      2015-06-22 20:44:41 GMT+0000 - 20:44 | Permalink

      Delightful, aren’t they. You might be interested in one of my favourites, The Annotated Mother Goose. This last weekend I watched the two part series The Secret River, based on Kate Grenville’s novel about early Australian settlement. The mother in the film is regularly singing nursery rhymes to her infant and the little children play out the nursery rhymes all in the context of early nineteenth century brutality — floggings, hangings. Their meanings cannot be hidden in such a society. Gallows humour.

    • Neil Godfrey
      2015-06-23 13:28:40 GMT+0000 - 13:28 | Permalink

      I have just come across this in Steven Pinker’s “Better Angels of Our Nature”… “Enjoy”:

      Even Mother Goose nursery rhymes, which mostly date from the 17th and 18th centuries, are
      jarring by the standards of what we let small children hear today.

      • Cock Robin is murdered in cold blood.
      • A single mother living in substandard housing has numerous illegitimate children and abuses them with whipping and starvation.
      • Two unsupervised children are allowed to go on a dangerous errand; Jack sustains a head injury that could leave him with brain damage, while Jill’s condition is unknown.
      • A drifter confesses that he threw an old man down the stairs.
      • Georgie Porgie sexually harasses underage girls, leaving them with symptoms of post-traumatic stress disorder.
      • Humpty Dumpty remains in critical condition after a crippling accident.
      • A negligent mother leaves a baby unattended on a treetop, with disastrous results.
      • A blackbird swoops down on a domestic employee hanging up laundry and maliciously wounds her nose.
      • Three vision-impaired mice are mutilated with a carving knife.
      • And here comes a candle to light you to bed; here comes a chopper to chop off your head!

      A recent article in the Archives of Diseases of Childhood measured the rates of violence in different genres of children’s entertainment. The television programs had 4.8 violent scenes per hour; the nursery rhymes had 52.2.

      • Reader
        2015-06-23 18:22:37 GMT+0000 - 18:22 | Permalink

        Thanks Neil,
        I had no clue about this information regarding nursery rhymes etc from this era.

  • David Ashton
    2015-06-23 21:27:08 GMT+0000 - 21:27 | Permalink

    Don’t have more kids than you can support, don’t stray alone in the woods, avoid suspected pedophiles, taking dodgy customers into your home can be risky, don’t leave your baby unattended, there are nasty people about.

    Some further thoughts: A stitch in time saves nine, when in Rome do as the Romans do, birds of a feather flock together.

    Not very “liberal”!

  • John
    2015-09-30 17:55:07 GMT+0000 - 17:55 | Permalink

    Ya that would be because ALL of Mesopotamia was the offspring of Adam. the story of creation became fragmented and adopted to fit the new cultures given birth by location and by certain people wanting to brand their culture. All of the earths population split off from this central area taking with it all the different versions that would be adapted again and again and again and again. Only the Hebrew texts preserve the original account of these events.

  • Leave a Reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

    This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.