2020-10-08

Trump Cultists Dying for Their Dear Leader

Creative Commons License

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.

by Neil Godfrey

David Cay Johnston

From David Cay Johnston of DC Report: Will Republican Cultists Die For Their Dear Leader?

Years ago when I was a devout member of a Christian cult I got a visit from a local public hospital rep asking me why I had not let my infant child be vaccinated against whooping cough. My child survived a severe attack of whooping cough by luck or chance but I thanked God for not letting him die. One of the great evils of some religious cults is that they reject science and choose to trust their distinctive world view to see them through any life and death crisis. In some places civil authorities intervene for the welfare of children who are endangered by their parents’ beliefs. Compare a Trump follower:

And what about the 11-month-old baby of Kayleigh McEnany, Trump’s press secretary? McEnany has tested positive after again and again showing her fealty to the imaged great leader by going mask-less. Does anyone doubt that if McEnany were a poor black or brown woman—or a Jew or Muslim in a Bible Belt county—that child protective services would be investigating whether to remove the infant Blake for her own safety?

Norman Swan: What’s your analysis of what’s going on in the Centres for Disease Control and the Food and Drug Administration? I mean, the Centres for Disease Control wrote the textbook on pandemic control.

Eric Topol: Well, somehow that textbook got lost or got thrown away. The reason why we failed so much is because both the CDC and the Food and Drug Administration were basically taken out. This has been a White House Trump-run response to the pandemic. Robert Redfield who runs the CDC has not had any presence. There are things, as I think you know, that are just extraordinary, just despicable how the weekly morbidity mortality report that the medical community relies upon was manipulated and censored. There were guidelines put out about not doing testing, not doing testing on people without symptoms but exposed. I mean, all sorts of things that were done to the CDC by Trump in the White House, by ill-informed advisors, a neuroradiologist that Trump brought in to crowd out Tony Fauci.

So we are in disarray. The agencies who we would depend on totally are not even being able to do what they need to do. The FDA has issued emergency use authorisation for convalescent plasma, claimed that it reduced mortality by 35%, which it has no data to support that, and made it in a so-called very historic breakthrough on the evening before the national convention for Trump. So we are seeing things that…you just can’t make this stuff up, it’s nightmarish.

ABC Radio National. “The US Response to the Coronavirus Pandemic.” October 2, 2020.

David Cay Johnston continued:

This is what happens when a cult arises. The leader is special and believers most demonstrate without even being asked that the messages the leader conveys have been internalized. And if he uses tricks and deceits to fool the public you must go along to remain in his good graces even if it exposes you and your newborn to sickness, lifelong health problems and even death.

The reason, rationality and civil debate envisioned by our Founders and Framers have no place in Trump’s anti-democratic cult. All that matters is loyalty to the leader, a loyalty that runs only one way.

Trump devotees do not believe in faith healing but as a movement they do believe in maintaining their political faith in living by anti-science, anti-intellectual, anti-modernist pronouncements of their leader. They justify their stance the same way each religious asserts and justifies its difference from other cults that have the same type of faith: appeals to special knowledge of their leaders not widely known to the public.

I recall Tamas Pataki’s description of fundamentalism as it applied not only to religious but also to political groups. Some of his points:

1. They (fundamentalists) are counter-modernist. It (fundamentalism) manifests itself as an attempt by “besieged believers” to find their refuge in arming themselves with an identity that is rooted in a past golden age. And this identity is acted out in an attempt to restore that “golden past”.

2. They (fundamentalists) are “generally assertive, clamorous, and often violent”.

3. They are “the Chosen”, “the Elect”, “the Saved”. And as such, they are “privileged” or “burdened” with a special mission on behalf of their deity and for the benefit of the world.

4. Public marks of distinction are needed to maintain their sense of superiority and distinctive identity. Not only for the purpose of maintaining that distinctive identity but also as “part of the narcissistic struggle to be considered unique and special.”

5. There is only one true religion; there is only one correct way of life; and these must be defended against inroads from other religions and secularism.

6. There is an inerrant holy book, prophet or charismatic leader to whom literal obedience is mandatory.

In the world of political populism the followers embrace the vision of their leader. Their whole sense of reality begins and ends with the pronouncements of their populist leader.

I never expected to see anything so retrograde taking over the United States, least of all at a time when following science and professionals is more necessary than ever to understand, admit and tackle so many major challenges. (Nor did I ever expect to see the “dear leader” propaganda videos that are undeniably a par with what we associate with totalitarian regimes, past and present.) The total denial of reality, the calling truth lies, calling dishonesty honesty, belief in bizarre conspiracy theories, it does look very much to me as though much of the United States has indeed broken itself off from reality and closeted itself in a cult fantasy world.

My god, if Biden-Harris win the coming election they better take on the root causes of all of this total madness:

Trump draws crowds because the majority of Americans have real economic grievances, as I’ve written about for decades including these recent DCReport pieces. Indeed, Trump ran for office using many of the phrases he heard me say on television about how Washington policies hurt 90% of Americans.

While he pledged in his inaugural address that “the forgotten men and women of our country will be forgotten no longer” his actions documented by DCReport show that he never gave them a thought.

The following two tabs change content below.

Neil Godfrey

Neil is the author of this post. To read more about Neil, see our About page.

Latest posts by Neil Godfrey (see all)



If you enjoyed this post, please consider donating to Vridar. Thanks!


10 thoughts on “Trump Cultists Dying for Their Dear Leader”

  1. “I never expected to see anything so retrograde taking over the United States”

    Why? Look at people, they are mostly willingly ignorant, superstitious, constantly fearful too-lazy-to-think primitives.

    1. A bit harsh, don’t you think? 😉 trump supporters fortunately are a minority in the U.S. and most of the world looks on what is happening there with dismay. And there are more reliable historical, economic, social, psychological, political explanations for their support for Trump. Even Hilary Clinton’s ill-chosen label “deplorables” has been opportunistically ripped from her fuller explanation.

      1. Neil, I live in Texas. I wouldn’t say “trump supporters fortunately are a minority in the U.S.” He was elected in 2016 and we don’t know what’s going to happen in 2020. Personally, I’m not a supporter but a lot of people I know are. I’m fearful he may be reelected. If so, I’m dreading what he will do. He’s a madman.

        1. Another Texas inhabitant. The big cities are generally blue, but the rest is generally red, and the gated suburbs are red. The non-gated suburbs are a more interesting tale.

          There is always idle talk of Texas going blue, but the pandemic has only intensified politics here, not changed them. It’ll happen in my lifetime, I think, but not this year.

          Haven’t read your blog in awhile, Neil – glad you’re still at it!

  2. Damn, Neil, as if Bidenists are any better, or K-Hive. Idk what happened to your objectivity, and David Kay Johnson is an establishment tool. You must know this!

    1. People who support Biden-Harris are “no better [presumably for the welfare of most Americans] than Trump”? Do you have a critically reasoned response to Johnson’s words quoted in the post?

      Or are you simply jaded and disillusioned totally with anything political in the U.S.? If so, would it not be more useful to try to become politically engaged in a positive way rather than let a “failed system” run its course unopposed?

  3. I’d like to see my taxes be higher. Way higher. I’d like to see more government regulation, leading to decreased economic activity and higher unemployment. I’d like to open up my 401k statement and have a syncopal episode that it’s dropped so much. I want my second amendment rights significantly curtailed. I want to see more peaceful protests that cause billions of dollars in property damages. I want open boarders, and, can we take it a little easier on China? What have they ever done to us. And lets pack the Supreme Court, 11, 13, whatever it takes to get our way. As there is no logic or evidence that you can produce to deny me my desires, if you disagree with me then you must be some kind of cultist.

    1. You have set out a list of things you fear, all of them having been conveniently articulated for you by Trump, and have concluded with a declaration that those fears are real and any attempt to suggest they are not is a lie. Your comment tells me you have found comfort and security in Trump, so much so that any criticism of him or his MO or his followers is a threat to that comfort and assurance you find in Trump.

      When people used to ask me what I would do if I found out one day that my faith was misplaced, I simply could not accept the premise of the question.

  4. Your labeling of roughly half of US voters as “cultists” is untrue, unsupported, and unbecoming. Name-calling is no way to win any debate. There may be a small subset of Trump supporters who fit your description of “cultist”, and I imagine the same exists on the left. From experience and observation I can tell you that the vast majority of Trump voters are boring working class conservatives who will vote to support their ideologies, and the candidate just happens to be Trump in this election. Options are limited: vote for Trump, don’t vote, or vote for a perceived radical left wing agenda. Trump is flawed, no doubt, but, you gotta dance with who brought you.
    I won’t do the endless back and forth, you get the last word if you want.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.